Why always him? The rise and fall of Balotelli

⏱ 4 min read  •  835 words

Related Teams

On 23 October 2011, Mario Balotelli scored in the 22nd minute at Old Trafford, lifted his Manchester City shirt and showed a message printed on the vest underneath: “Why always me?” City went on to win 6-1, the worst home defeat of Sir Alex Ferguson’s time at Manchester United. Balotelli scored twice. Only 36 hours earlier, firefighters had been called to his house in Didsbury after fireworks were set off in a bathroom.

That is 15 years ago now. The image of a 21-year-old staring blankly at the Stretford End is still one of the best-known pictures in Premier League history. It also captures the whole of Balotelli’s career: plenty of talent, plenty of drama, and the feeling that both followed him wherever he went.

The derby that defined him

City’s former kitman Les Chapman later said Balotelli asked for the slogan to be printed on the Monday before the game. It was planned, not a spur-of-the-moment idea. In a 2012 interview with Noel Gallagher, Balotelli said the message was meant for the press, who he felt wrote about him whatever he did.

The days around the derby gave the papers plenty of material. Balotelli was soon named an ambassador for Greater Manchester’s firework safety campaign. In the game itself, he scored City’s first goal and then a second after the break. Jonny Evans was sent off for United, and late goals from Edin Dzeko and David Silva turned the derby into a rout. City won the title on goal difference that season, so the five-goal margin turned out to matter.

Balotelli then had a hand in the most famous moment of all. On the final day against QPR, he slid the ball into Sergio Aguero’s path for the 93rd-minute winner, 93:20 on the clock. It is often noted that this was his only Premier League assist.

Brilliance and chaos

Roberto Mancini knew him better than anyone. He gave Balotelli his debut at Inter Milan at the age of 17 and paid around £24m to bring him to City in August 2010. Balotelli won a Serie A title and a treble medal at Inter under Jose Mourinho in 2010, though he had a stormy relationship with Mourinho. At City he won the FA Cup in 2011, when he was named man of the match in the final against Stoke, and the title in 2012.

Euro 2012 was probably the peak of his career. He scored twice against Germany in the semi-final in Warsaw. For the second goal he took his shirt off and stood still with his arms flexed, an image almost as famous as the one from Old Trafford. Italy lost the final 4-0 to Spain.

The trouble kept coming. There were red cards, darts thrown at youth-team players, a failed attempt at a backheel finish in a pre-season friendly against LA Galaxy, and finally a training-ground scuffle with Mancini in January 2013. Days later he was sold to AC Milan. Brendan Rodgers brought him to Liverpool in 2014 for about £16m, and it went badly. He scored once in 16 Premier League appearances and was criticised for swapping shirts with Real Madrid’s Pepe at half-time of a Champions League game.

The long goodbye

He did rebuild his game at Nice, scoring more than 40 goals across three seasons from 2016 under Lucien Favre and Patrick Vieira. After that the moves came quickly: Marseille, his hometown club Brescia, Monza in Serie B, Adana Demirspor in Turkey, Sion in Switzerland, back to Adana, and then a short spell at Genoa in 2024-25 with very little playing time. He won the last of his 36 Italy caps, in which he scored 14 goals, in 2018.

In January 2026 he signed for Al Ittifaq, a Dubai club in the UAE’s second tier. Reports counted it as the 14th club of his professional career. He turned 36 in August.

Balotelli’s career is more than a list of funny stories. He is often used as an example of how badly a big talent can be managed. Black and of Ghanaian heritage, he was born in Palermo, raised by a foster family in Brescia, and only granted Italian citizenship at 18. He suffered racist abuse in Italian grounds throughout his career, and he has repeatedly said the English tabloids “went overboard” with him. That gives the T-shirt a different meaning. It was a provocation, but it was also a fair complaint from a young player whose every mistake was front-page news.

What it cost him is easier to measure. He was in a title-winning squad at 21 and a European Championship final at 21. By 25 he was a Liverpool flop. Many of the players he lined up with in 2012 went on to dominate their clubs for a decade, while he moved from loan to free transfer to second divisions. Fifteen years on, the question on his shirt still gets the same mixed answer from those who watched him: partly unfair treatment, and partly his own doing.

Ahmad Ali
Written by
Ahmad Ali

Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.

1195 articles published