By Ahmad Ali, Sports Editor
Andy Robertson should have spent Monday night celebrating. In St Gallen he won his 103rd cap and passed Kenny Dalglish to become Scotland’s most-capped men’s player. Instead, the captain fronted up after a 4-0 Nations League thrashing by Switzerland and said: “We don’t have time, the players do not have time, we have got to step up.” The defeat ended Sebastien Pocognoli’s first campaign as head coach with two wins in six matches, both against bottom side North Macedonia. Three months after he replaced Steve Clarke, the question is now being asked openly: is it already time for the Belgian to go?
A night that summed up a campaign
Scotland went behind in the 22nd minute when Lewis Ferguson turned the ball into his own net. Aaron Hickey went off injured before half-time, and the game was gone within six minutes of the restart. Winsley Boteli scored in the 47th minute, Alvyn Sanches added a third four minutes later, and substitute Zeki Amdouni made it four in the 89th minute.
The opposition made it worse. Swiss coach Murat Yakin started six players with six caps or fewer, and three of them scored. BBC Scotland described the hosts as “a Switzerland B side playing in third gear”.
The table is just as harsh. Scotland finished third in Group B1 with seven points from 18, behind Switzerland and Slovenia. That means:
- No promotion play-off spot next year, so Scotland stay in League B for the next Nations League.
- Worse seeding for next month’s Euro 2028 qualifying draw.
- Five goals in six games, two of them penalties.
- A home defeat by Slovenia and a laboured 2-1 home win over North Macedonia on Friday, when Hampden booed at half-time.
Pocognoli’s defence
Pocognoli did not accept that the scoreline told the whole story. “The score is heavy with the 4-0, but I don’t think it’s a reflection of the game, if I’m really honest and objective,” he told BBC Scotland. He pointed to chances missed by Ferguson and Scott McTominay, and said his substitutions “made an impact and we should have scored two goals in that period”.
“So the next step is to have the quality to just finish this action,” he added, “and the more we have games together, the more we will try to fix these things.”
Before the trip to Switzerland, he made clear he expects to be given time. John McGinn had suggested the coach’s ideas could take as long as 18 months to bed in. Asked whether he would get that long, Pocognoli said: “Yes, because it’s the timing of my contract. In 18 months it will be the time of the Euros.” He also conceded that “for sure, it needs to be quicker”. He said he does not read the press and that half-time boos at Hampden have “been like this for years”.
Dressing-room doubts and tactical questions
What stands out is how candid the senior players have been. Asked whether Scotland were on the right path, McGinn replied: “Impossible for me to say yes.” After the Slovenia defeat, Robertson said his side had been out-played and out-fought. After St Gallen he went further: “These supporters who travel everywhere, are they going to give us time? No. Are the people inside Hampden going to give us time? No.”
The criticism of Pocognoli’s approach is consistent. He wants intense, high pressing, and the squad has not shown it can play that way. BBC Scotland’s assessment was blunt: the system “has made Scotland a disjointed soft touch”. Players push forward and leave space behind them, the structure breaks down too often, and more experienced coaches have found the set-up “easily exploited”. Pocognoli has shown little sign of changing it. “I have my philosophy and we will try to go from this,” he said before the Switzerland game.
The comparison with Clarke is hard to avoid. Clarke had his own bad nights. McGinn has recalled the 4-0 defeat in Russia in 2019, when Scotland conceded four goals in 27 minutes. But Clarke fixed the structure and took Scotland to three major tournaments. That record is why the Scottish FA’s decision to replace him with a coach who had little international experience was always going to be judged quickly.
What happens next?
The pressure now falls on the governing body. Chief executive Ian Maxwell and chief football officer Craig Mulholland led a worldwide search that ended with Pocognoli, and president Mike Mulraney backed the appointment. So far there has been no public statement on the coach’s position, and nothing suggests a change is imminent. Sacking a coach after six games would also be an admission that the recruitment process failed.
The timing helps both sides. Scotland do not play again until March, when Euro 2028 qualifying begins. With the qualifying format generous to most nations, Scotland are widely expected to reach the finals. That gives the SFA a reason to stay patient. It also takes away Pocognoli’s best excuse, because there is little room to blame a hard road if Scotland stumble.
My verdict: sacking him now would be premature, but this cannot carry on. A 4-0 defeat to a second-string Swiss side, a squad captain saying publicly that time has run out, and a vice-captain who cannot say the team is heading in the right direction add up to a serious warning. Before March, Pocognoli needs an honest conversation with his senior players and a more practical approach that suits the squad he has. If the first qualifiers look like this autumn, the SFA will have to act.
Robertson called the long break until March “a tough one to swallow”. For Pocognoli, it may be the last chance to show he is the right man for the job.
—
I checked the facts against BBC Scotland, ESPN/PA, Sky Sports and Brit Brief coverage from 16–17 November. Pocognoli is still in charge. No source reports a sacking or an SFA statement on his position, so the article doesn’t claim either.
– **What’s left out:** none of the sources gives his contract length, the exact date he was appointed (only “August”) or the scores of three of the six games, so those aren’t in the piece.
– **Paraphrases:** “out-played and out-fought” (Robertson) and “easily exploited” (the tactics criticism) are not exact quotes in the sources.
– **Judgement calls:** the closing verdict is written as Ahmad Ali’s opinion. The line that Scotland are “widely expected to reach the finals” rests on a BBC writer calling the next Euros “a gimme”.
I’ve saved these facts to memory for later pieces on this story.
Sources:
– [BBC piece (syndicated copy)](https://jingletree.com/what-s-the-story-with-scotland-boss-pocognoli-is-it-time-to-go-308740.html)
– [ESPN – Pocognoli reaction](https://www.espn.com/soccer/story/_/id/50505776/scotland-loss-switzerland-sebastien-pocognoli)
– [ESPN – match page](https://www.espn.com/soccer/match/_/gameId/401861186)
– [Sky Sports – match report](https://www.skysports.com/football/switzerland-vs-scotland/report/554127)
– [Brit Brief – Hampden boos](https://britbrief.co.uk/sports/football/pocognoli-shrugs-off-boos-and-insists-scotland-can-be-great-again.html)
– [Yahoo – “old guard” piece](https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/scotland-still-too-reliant-old-075749650.html)



