The 3pm football blackout: outdated or still relevant in 2026?

⏱ 4 min read  •  1,039 words

Related Teams

The Prime Minister has entered one of English football’s oldest arguments. In remarks reported by PA on Sunday 15 November, Andy Burnham said he would “urge a bit of caution” about scrapping the Saturday 3pm television blackout, “because it does protect the income of lower league clubs.” The Premier League, the EFL and the Football Association will all have a say before the next round of domestic rights sales. The question in front of them is whether a rule written in the 1960s still makes sense in 2026.

Supporters who stream their football and watch it on their phones see the blackout as a relic. Many people who run clubs below the top flight see it as the last thing protecting the gate receipts they depend on. Whether they keep it or scrap it, the decision will shape the English game for a generation.

What the blackout is and where it came from

The rule comes from Article 48 of UEFA’s statutes. It lets a national association protect a two-and-a-half-hour window from live broadcasts. In England the FA uses it to ban live coverage of matches between 2.45pm and 5.15pm on Saturdays. The Scottish FA does the same in Scotland. The ban applies when 50% or more of matches in the top two divisions kick off at the same time. It covers foreign leagues too, which is why UK viewers cannot watch a La Liga or Serie A game in that window.

The idea dates from the 1960s, when clubs feared that live television would empty the terraces. Burnley chairman Bob Lord is widely credited as one of its loudest supporters. The thinking was simple: if fans can watch the best teams from their armchairs, they will stop paying to watch their local side. Sixty years on, that is still the main argument for keeping it.

The rule has been tested before. In 2011 the European Court of Justice ruled for Karen Murphy, the Portsmouth publican who had shown matches using a Greek satellite decoder. The ruling unsettled the exclusive-territory model behind Premier League rights. In 2020, when Covid-19 forced matches behind closed doors, every game was shown live and the blackout was effectively suspended. Supporters saw that it could be done, and many have not forgotten it.

The case for scrapping it

Those who want the rule gone point to how much the market has changed. The current Premier League domestic deal, with Sky Sports and TNT Sports, runs from 2025 to 2029. It includes 270 live matches a season, up from 200 in the previous cycle. Almost every fixture outside the protected slot is now on television. The fans who miss out are mostly those whose club happens to kick off at 3pm on a Saturday.

Illegal streaming is the other big argument. Critics say the blackout does not stop people watching. It just sends them to unlicensed streams, and that money goes to pirates rather than to the sport. Broadcasters, and the clubs who rely on their money, would like to sell that window legally. The Premier League’s most valuable product is still Saturday afternoon football, and at the moment it cannot be shown live in its own country.

Pressure is also building north of the border. The SPFL’s tender for its next rights cycle is reported to offer the chance to show every match live. If Scotland goes first, it will be harder for England to argue that the old model cannot change.

The case for keeping it

Burnham’s argument is the one the blackout’s defenders have always made. “If you have effectively wall-to-wall Premier League football at any time, it takes away perhaps the incentive to go and watch the football league or non-league,” he said. “I’m not going to take the pure consumer view here. I’ll take the health of football approach to this particular issue.”

For clubs in League Two and the National League, matchday income is not extra money on top of a TV deal. It pays the wages. A small drop in walk-up crowds on a wet November afternoon can decide whether a club breaks even. Nobody can be sure how many fans would stay at home if Arsenal or Liverpool were on live at 3pm. That uncertainty is the point: if the rule went and the gamble failed, it would be very hard to undo.

Burnham also criticised the way existing broadcast scheduling treats supporters. “It doesn’t give any regard, actually, as far as I can see, to travelling supporters,” he said. He pointed to Monday night fixtures that send fans from the north-east to the north-west, and to “very early kick-offs on Saturday”. His point is that showing more matches on television has already cost match-going fans something, and that removing the 3pm protection would add to that cost.

What happens next

No change is imminent. Premier League chief executive Richard Masters told talkSPORT in August that Article 48 is “not just us involved in the decision. It’s us, the EFL and the FA.” He added: “I’d say in about 18 months time we’ll come back to that decision about whether article 48 should remain or not.” Reports suggest any change would apply to the next Premier League, EFL and SPFL rights cycles, from 2029-30.

That leaves time for a proper debate, and it needs one. The blackout is not out of date just because it is old, and it is not sacred just because it is traditional. The honest answer to this article’s question is that it is still relevant, but it is being asked to do a harder job every season. A rule designed to protect crowds now also protects a business model, and pirates are profiting from the gap.

The governing bodies should keep the principle and update how it works. That could mean a narrower window, a guaranteed share of new revenue for the pyramid, or a trial that is properly monitored before anything becomes permanent. Scrapping the rule outright for a one-off windfall would risk the clubs that make English football more than just its top 20. As Burnham put it, the first priority is “protecting the football pyramid”. The game’s administrators would do well to agree.

Ahmad Ali, Sports Editor

Ahmad Ali
Written by
Ahmad Ali

Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.

1196 articles published