‘He’s become Scots’ chief creative force’ – how the players rated

'He's become Scots' chief creative force' - how the players rated
3 min read  •  689 words

Scotland’s expanded 48-team World Cup campaign continued in Houston on Saturday with a 2-1 victory over Haiti at NRG Stadium, and at the centre of everything was Scott McTominay. The Napoli midfielder set up Che Adams for the opener inside 12 minutes, drove forward for the move that produced Lyndon Dykes’ 67th-minute winner, and finished the night with a 96 per cent pass completion rate in the Haiti half. Steve Clarke called him “our chief creative force” in his post-match address. The numbers, and the eye test, back the manager up.

McTominay the conductor as Scotland edge a scare

Haiti, ranked 83rd in the world and making only their third World Cup appearance, refused to be the cameo opponents the script demanded. Duckens Nazon levelled in the 41st minute after Jack Hendry was caught flat-footed by a Frantzdy Pierrot flick, and for a 20-minute spell either side of the interval Scotland looked rattled. Angus Gunn turned a Danley Jean Jacques drive onto the post in the 54th minute, the closest Haiti came to a famous result.

What changed the rhythm was McTominay dropping deeper to collect from Hendry and Grant Hanley, then carrying the ball through the lines himself. The winning goal came from one such surge: a 40-yard run, a disguised slip to John McGinn, and Dykes finishing first time from the cutback. It was Scotland’s 14th goal of the tournament cycle in which McTominay had either scored or assisted — more than any other Scotland midfielder in the modern era.

How the players rated

Our writers scored the Scotland side immediately after the final whistle. Reader ratings remain open below — return 90 minutes after full-time to see the merged final marks.

  • Angus Gunn 7 — The post-save off Jean Jacques was the moment. Otherwise untested but composed in distribution.
  • Aaron Hickey 6 — Got forward willingly, defended his flank well until tiring in the 70th minute.
  • Jack Hendry 5 — Beaten in the air for the Haiti goal and lucky not to concede a penalty for a 58th-minute trip on Pierrot.
  • Grant Hanley 7 — Captain’s display. Won nine of his eleven aerial duels and organised the back line through the rocky spell.
  • Andy Robertson 7 — Drove the team forward in the second half. His delivery from the left created three chances.
  • Billy Gilmour 6 — Tidy without ever dictating. Replaced by Kenny McLean on 74 minutes.
  • Scott McTominay 9 — Goal, assist, and the gravitational pull around which Scotland organised. Man of the match.
  • John McGinn 7 — Energy in midfield and the unselfish square ball for the winner.
  • Ryan Christie 6 — Industrious without finding the killer pass. Withdrawn on 68 minutes.
  • Che Adams 7 — Took his goal smartly and led the line intelligently against a physical centre-back pairing.
  • Lyndon Dykes 8 — A controversial selection ahead of Lawrence Shankland, vindicated by the winning goal and two assists for himself in build-up.

Among the Haiti players, Nazon (8) was the standout — his goal aside, he ran Hendry ragged for an hour. Goalkeeper Johny Placide (7) made saves from McGinn and Adams that kept the contest alive into the closing stages.

What it means for Group H

Three points lifts Scotland to the top of Group H on goal difference ahead of Wednesday’s meeting with Mexico in Atlanta. Under the expanded format the eight best third-placed teams advance to the round of 32, so a single defeat is rarely fatal — but Clarke will know that beating Haiti was the expected outcome, not the achievement. The performance level required against Mexico, who beat Norway 3-0 in their opener, is several rungs higher.

The deeper read is that Scotland have finally found a tournament-grade No. 8. McTominay’s 14 goal involvements across qualifying and the opening match exceed anything posted by a Scotland midfielder since Paul McStay’s run at Italia ’90. If he stays fit through the group stage, Scotland have a realistic path beyond it for the first time since 1974 — when, as ever, the Tartan Army went home unbeaten and eliminated. This squad has the chance to rewrite that sentence.

Ahmad Ali
Written by
Ahmad Ali

Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.

209 articles published