Trailing 1-0 with 15 minutes left against DR Congo, ranked 58th in the world, England were staring at the kind of tournament exit that reshapes careers and haunts federations. Harry Kane spared them. His two goals between the 79th and 90th minutes at Atlanta Stadium turned a night of dread into a 2-1 win and a place in the World Cup last 16. But as BBC Sport’s Phil McNulty writes, the scoreline flattered a performance that exposed every fault line Thomas Tuchel has yet to weld shut — and Mexico, on Saturday, will not offer the same forgiveness.
England have now conceded the opening goal in two of their four matches at this tournament and led at half-time in only one. For a squad assembled at a cost north of £700m, the numbers read like an indictment. Progression papers over the cracks; it does not fill them.
The midfield that keeps disappearing
The most alarming recurring theme is England’s loss of control in central areas. Against DR Congo, Declan Rice and Jude Bellingham were repeatedly bypassed as the Congolese pressed in waves, winning the second balls that England could not. For a 20-minute spell either side of the interval, Tuchel’s side did not register a single shot on target and surrendered possession in their own half 11 times.
This is not new. It echoed the sterile passages against Serbia in the group stage, when England managed 68% possession but only two efforts of note. The problem is structural: Bellingham drifts high to influence the game, leaving Rice isolated as a lone screen in front of a defence that then retreats towards its own goal. Tuchel spoke before the tournament of building “a team that suffocates opponents.” Too often, England have suffocated themselves.
The obvious remedy is a third midfielder — Adam Wharton or Kobbie Mainoo — to give Rice a partner and Bellingham licence to attack without leaving a hole behind him. Whether Tuchel trusts a reshape at this stage, having stuck rigidly to his 4-2-3-1, is the first question of the knockout rounds.
Over-reliance on a 32-year-old captain
Kane’s double took his tournament tally to five and confirmed, again, that he is the difference between this England side and mediocrity. That is precisely the concern. Three of England’s four goals at the World Cup have come from their captain; the supporting cast of Bukayo Saka, Phil Foden and Cole Palmer have combined for one.
The historical warning is stark. England’s most painful modern failures — Iceland in 2016, the group-stage stumble against the USA in Qatar — came when the talent around the striker went missing at the decisive moment. A team that funnels everything through one 32-year-old forward is one hamstring, one suspension, one quiet night away from elimination.
- Kane: 5 goals, 3 assists across four matches
- Saka, Foden, Palmer, Bellingham combined: 1 goal
- England shots on target per game: down from 6.2 in qualifying to 3.5 here
Tuchel needs his wide players to threaten in transition and his No. 10 to arrive in the box, rather than orbiting Kane and waiting for him to conjure something. Mexico’s back line, marshalled by the excellent César Montes, will not be dragged around by one man alone.
What Saturday demands
Mexico represent a step up in every dimension: quicker, more cohesive, and roared on by what will effectively be a home crowd across the venues. They have conceded just twice in four games and carry genuine threat through Santiago Giménez and the tireless Edson Álvarez, who will relish the space England keep gifting in midfield.
For Tuchel, appointed in part to deliver the tournament nous his predecessors lacked, this is the examination that matters. He was hired to win knockout football, not to survive it. Beating DR Congo by the width of Kane’s instinct is not the evidence England’s hierarchy craved when they broke with tradition to appoint a German head coach.
The tools are there. Few squads at this World Cup can match England’s depth, and none can match the ruthlessness of their captain in front of goal. But depth unused is depth wasted, and a game plan that leans on late individual brilliance is not a plan at all. England were 15 minutes from humiliation on Wednesday. Against Mexico, Tuchel must ensure they are never that close again — because the next time, there may be no Kane, and no reprieve.
Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.
355 articles published
