The umpires at Lord’s called time on the third day of the second Test at 6.32pm on Saturday, with the floodlights burning, the sun breaking through and England 177 for seven, 357 runs ahead of Pakistan. Within minutes the covers were being wheeled off. Nasser Hussain, watching from the Sky Sports commentary box, called the decision “a joke” — and the paying public at the Nursery End, who had sat through rain delay after rain delay for 24.5 overs of cricket, were in no mood to disagree.
It was the third consecutive day of this Test compromised by weather. Day one did not begin until 12.20pm and ended with England 248 for nine, Mohammad Abbas taking 4-56 and Mohammad Ali 3-67. Day two belonged to Ollie Robinson, whose 4-11 from 13 overs, backed by Jofra Archer’s 3-26, dismissed Pakistan for 110. Day three offered roughly two hours of cricket in total. That the last of it was removed on the grounds of poor visibility, at the point when visibility was arguably at its best, is what turned frustration into anger.
Bright enough for the members, dark enough for the meters
The detail that stung most was the refund arithmetic. Under the ticketing terms, spectators qualify for a 50 per cent refund when fewer than 31 overs are bowled in a day. Play stopped 6.1 overs short of that mark. Lord’s will be writing cheques, which is small consolation for anyone who had travelled to St John’s Wood for a day that delivered less than a Twenty20 innings.
The mechanics are not the umpires’ invention. Since batters lost the right to appeal against the light in 2010, officials are required to make the call themselves, using a light meter reading benchmarked against the level recorded at the previous stoppage. Once that reading is logged, it becomes the ceiling for the rest of the match. If the meters said no, Ahsan Raza and his colleague had limited room to say yes, however bright it looked from the Pavilion.
That is precisely Hussain’s argument, and he has been making it for years. He described the light-related delays during England’s Test against Pakistan at the Ageas Bowl in 2020 as “disgraceful”. Joe Root, then as now England’s captain, said afterwards that the bad-light regulations should be reviewed. Six years on, nothing material has changed, and a Lord’s crowd has been sent home under floodlights in sunshine.
What England lost, and what Pakistan gained
England will be irritated for cricketing reasons rather than commercial ones. Dan Lawrence was unbeaten on 50 from 66 balls, having reached his fifty in 64 with a slog-sweep for six off the spinner Ali Usman. It followed his 51 at Headingley in the first Test, where England won by an innings and 103 runs. Harry Brook had made 34 from 56 before Abbas found him, and Robinson was 2 not out at the close.
Abbas, who has tormented England throughout this series, removed Emilio Gay lbw for 31 after the opener had added a single to his overnight score, and then had Jamie Smith caught at midwicket for seven. Mohammad Ali took Gus Atkinson lbw to finish with 2-54. Pakistan’s bowlers have done their work; their batters have not, having been dismissed for 171, 135 and now 110 in three attempts on this tour.
The lost hour matters because England need overs, not runs. With two days remaining and more rain forecast, every delivery not bowled edges the match towards a draw that would keep Pakistan alive at 1-0 down with one to play. Head coach Sarfaraz Ahmed said his side wanted to keep the target below 350. They are already past that figure, and Lord’s has never seen a successful fourth-innings chase beyond West Indies’ 344 for one in 1984.
The bigger problem is the calendar, not the cloud
English cricket cannot legislate for an August of low pressure systems, but it can decide what it does about the light. The obvious remedies — allowing play to continue under floodlights unless conditions are genuinely dangerous, or handing umpires discretion to override a meter reading when both captains are content — have been debated repeatedly without resolution. The counter-argument, made forcefully by Zak Crawley in 2020, is that a fast bowler operating in gloom can cause life-changing injuries. Nobody seriously disputes that. The dispute is over whether a fixed meter number, set hours earlier in worse conditions, is the right instrument for judging it.
Hussain’s intervention will not change a playing condition overnight. But when a former England captain, a full house at Lord’s and a batting side pushing for a series win all reach the same conclusion at the same moment, the game’s administrators have a problem that is no longer about weather. England resume on Sunday needing quick runs, a declaration and a functioning sky.
Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.
705 articles published
