By Ahmad Ali, Sports Editor
Twelve minutes into the new Premier League season, Keane Lewis-Potter collected a pass from Mamadou Sangare and drove Brentford in front against a Tottenham Hotspur team assembled at a cost of £337m. By half-time Vitaly Janelt had added a second and Spurs had not registered a single shot on target. Four minutes after the restart Michael Kayode made it three. Roberto De Zerbi’s first competitive fixture of a season he had spent all summer building towards had turned into a post-mortem before the hour.
Brentford 3-0 Tottenham at the Gtech Community Stadium on Saturday matched Spurs’ joint-heaviest opening-day defeat in the Premier League era. It could have been worse: Igor Thiago struck the post from the penalty spot on 56 minutes. Brentford finished with 26 attempts to Tottenham’s nine, 40 touches in the visitors’ penalty area to Spurs’ 18, and an expected-goals total of 3.94 against 0.47. Those are not the numbers of a bad afternoon. They are the numbers of a mismatch.
Out-fought, and De Zerbi said so
To his credit, the Italian did not reach for the usual first-day alibis. “We suffered physically,” De Zerbi said. “We were not ready to fight the duels; we made a lot of mistakes in the timing of the pressure.” He went further: “We didn’t play well. We didn’t fight in the right way. We didn’t remember the last season, because all of these players are good people and people with value and memory — but we lost too many duels.”
That last sentence is the whole story. Richarlison won two of his eight duels. Jan Paul van Hecke, a £52m signing from Brighton, won two of seven. Archie Gray, captaining the side, was blunter than his manager: “They just out-fought us all over the park. It wasn’t good enough.” Watching from the Sky Sports gantry, Jamie Redknapp called it “a team of strangers” — individually credible, collectively unrecognisable as a unit. Five Spurs players made their debuts. None of them looked as though they had met the others before Friday.
The bill, and what it bought
Tottenham’s summer was the most aggressive of any Premier League club. Sandro Tonali arrived from Newcastle in a deal that can reach £100m. Mateus Fernandes cost £85m from West Ham, comfortably a club record. Van Hecke came for £52m at the third attempt. Andy Robertson, Marcos Senesi and Martin Dubravka were added on free transfers, an experienced spine bolted on at no fee. Total outlay: £337m, against roughly £142m recouped through the sales of Cristian Romero to Atletico Madrid, Luka Vuskovic to Brighton and Djed Spence to Inter.
It is not finished. Spurs have an agreed deal in place for Savinho from Manchester City worth around £75m, and have registered interest in Omar Marmoush before the window closes. Speaking on Friday, 24 hours before kick-off, De Zerbi defended the scale of it all: “For me, no pressure, and it’s not a problem. I don’t know why the people don’t love it if Tottenham becomes better. This is Tottenham, not another smaller team.” He added that the board “kept their word, they kept what they said before I came in March.”
They did. That is precisely why Saturday stung. The money was the easy part. What Tottenham cannot buy in a single window is the thing De Zerbi identified within 90 minutes of the season starting: a squad that expects to win contested balls in the 12th minute of a hot August afternoon in west London.
Two years of 17th place do not wash off in one summer
The context matters. Spurs have finished 17th in each of the last two seasons. The most recent survival was secured only on the final day, a 1-0 win over Everton settled by Joao Palhinha’s 43rd-minute header from a corner, and by a margin of two points over West Ham. De Zerbi was the third head coach of that campaign, appointed on 31 March after Thomas Frank was dismissed in February and Igor Tudor’s 44-day interim spell ended without resolution. Eleven points from the final six matches kept Tottenham up.
That rescue job bought De Zerbi a five-year contract and the transfer budget to match. But a dressing room does not reset in June. Players who have spent two seasons losing — including a Champions League last-16 exit to Atletico Madrid and a Super Cup final lost on penalties to Paris Saint-Germain — carry the habits of losing into September. Squad turnover of this scale can dilute a bad culture; it can also simply replace the faces without changing the pattern, which is what happened at the Gtech.
Where Spurs go from here
There are reasons for patience. It is one match. Five debutants had barely trained together. Tottenham have no European football this season for the first time since 2022-23, which gives De Zerbi something his predecessors did not have: a clear week between most fixtures to coach the pressing structure whose timing he criticised.
The risk is that the noise arrives faster than the coaching does. Tottenham sit bottom of the table after one weekend with the most expensive squad they have ever fielded, and the questions on Saturday were not about tactics but about temperament. De Zerbi has already given his own diagnosis. Fixing it will take something the £337m did not include.
Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.
651 articles published
