Brydon Carse has been charged by the Cricket Regulator with bringing the game into disrepute over an incident outside a Derby nightclub in August, but the England fast bowler remains available for selection and his central contract is unaffected.
The 31-year-old is alleged to have breached Regulation 3.2 of the ECB’s Professional Conduct Regulations, which states that “no participant may conduct themself in a manner, do any act or make any omission at any time which is improper or which may be prejudicial to the interests of cricket or which may bring the ECB, the game of cricket or any cricketer or group of cricketers into disrepute.”
The case will now be referred to the independent Cricket Discipline Panel for adjudication. Sanctions available to the panel range from a formal reprimand to a playing ban.
What happened in Derby
Carse was arrested at around 4am on Sunday 23 August on suspicion of being drunk and disorderly, in the hours after Durham had beaten Derbyshire in a County Championship match. Footage of the bowler in handcuffs circulated widely on social media. He was subsequently de-arrested.
Derbyshire Police separately investigated an allegation of assault in Derby city centre linked to the night. That investigation was closed last month with no further action taken against Carse. The Cricket Regulator’s process is independent of the police one, and a decision not to prosecute does not resolve a disrepute charge — the thresholds and the questions are different.
The ECB has declined to go further while the panel process runs. “Brydon now has the opportunity to respond through the established process,” a spokesperson said. “As we do not wish to prejudge the outcome, it would not be appropriate for us to comment further.”
The sporting consequences have already been substantial, and they arrived long before the charge. Carse was dropped from the Test squad for the second Test against Pakistan at Lord’s within days of the incident and was not recalled for the series finale at Edgbaston, with Hampshire’s 23-year-old Sonny Baker retaining the seam slot. He was then left out of the T20I and ODI squads for the Sri Lanka series, and on Thursday he was omitted again from the 16-man group for this month’s one-day tri-series in Pakistan — a squad built around Harry Brook as captain, with Mason Crane recalled.
Available, but not selected
The distinction the ECB is drawing matters. Carse has not been suspended, has not been stood down, and remains in the second year of a two-year central contract that the charge has not altered. He is eligible. He is simply not being picked, with selection understood to be assessed tour by tour.
Both captains have been careful but clear. Brook, who leads the white-ball sides, said Carse “just needs time away from the international scene” and is “working on a few things behind the scenes.” Test captain Joe Root, who has moved to tighten standards in the dressing room since taking over, described himself as “hacked off” by alcohol-related incidents while characterising Carse as “very upset, very apologetic.”
That is not the language of a player who has been written off, but nor is it the language of an imminent recall.
What it means from here
This is Carse’s second disciplinary entanglement in two and a half years. In May 2024 he accepted a 16-month ban — 13 months of it suspended — for placing 303 bets on cricket between 2017 and 2019, most of them while rehabilitating from injury at home. He served three months and came back to build the best fast-bowling case in the England setup.
The playing record is the reason this is a selection problem rather than an afterthought:
- 14 Tests, 58 wickets at 30.18, best figures of 6-42 since his debut against Pakistan in October 2024
- 30 ODIs, 34 wickets, including a five-for against Pakistan in 2021
- 14 T20Is, 20 wickets at 20.60
England have a crowded winter and a thin stock of high-pace, hit-the-deck bowlers who can also bat. The white-ball tour of Australia runs from 13 November to 2 December, followed by three Tests in South Africa beginning at the Wanderers on 17 December and finishing in Cape Town on 7 January.
Whether Carse features depends on two things resolving in his favour: the Cricket Discipline Panel, expected to hear the case within weeks, and the private judgement of a leadership group that has made conduct a stated priority. The first is a formal process with a defined range of outcomes. The second has no hearing date at all.
Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.
931 articles published
