Former Australia captain Michael Clarke has called for the investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering scandal to be reopened, saying supporters of the national side “can’t trust what’s real” after Usman Khawaja’s claim that the whole team knew sandpaper was being used on the ball in Cape Town.
Clarke also questioned why current Test captain Pat Cummins, one of the four bowlers in that Newlands Test, has not responded. His comments put him at odds with Cricket Australia, whose chief executive Todd Greenberg has said there is “no compelling reason” to revisit the case.
“They can’t trust what’s real. They don’t know the truth until this gets reopened and the truth comes out,” Clarke told 2DayFM. “We had the chance in 2018. The truth didn’t come out. We had the chance in 2021 when [Cameron Bancroft] made those comments.”
Clarke turns the spotlight on Cummins
Khawaja, who batted at number three in the March 2018 Test against South Africa, writes in his autobiography Sabr that the entire team knew about the plan to alter the ball. He also says sandpaper was in use during the previous Test at Port Elizabeth. Clarke said that claim needed investigating as well.
“For me, right now, there’s more questions than answers,” said Clarke, who captained Australia in 47 Tests. “I want to know, firstly, did everyone know? Because certain players have come out and said they didn’t.”
He then turned to Cummins, who became Test captain in November 2021.
“I can’t believe we haven’t heard from Pat Cummins yet, the Australian captain,” Clarke said. “Steve Smith lost his job. If this doesn’t happen, Tim Paine never captains Australia. And neither does Pat Cummins.”
Smith was banned for 12 months and lost the captaincy, and Paine succeeded him. David Warner was also banned for a year, and Bancroft, the player caught on camera with the sandpaper, was banned for nine months. Warner said on Monday that Khawaja’s account was “100% accurate.”
Cummins has not commented publicly since extracts from the book were published. Fellow bowlers Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon have not responded either.
Starc stands by bowlers’ account as CA holds firm
Mitchell Starc, the fourth member of that attack, spoke at a season launch event in Sydney and said his position had not changed.
“Obviously, there’s differing opinions of eight years ago. We were heavily grilled through the process at the time, since,” he said. “I guess I won’t speak on behalf of the bowlers – but, where I stand, my opinion hasn’t changed. We weren’t aware it was taken on the field to be tampered with. We saw it on the big screen in Cape Town.”
Starc said Khawaja’s Port Elizabeth claim was the “first I was aware of any of that taking place in PE.” He added that he had not read the book “and probably won’t”.
Before Clarke’s intervention, Greenberg told Sports Entertainment Network that CA would not reopen the case. He said he had “huge respect” for Khawaja giving his version of events, but added: “There are specific details in his book that contradict the versions that have been provided by others.
“We’re comfortable with the outcome of the investigation based on the information we’ve received. We don’t see any compelling reason to open the investigation or revisit this again. I don’t think there’s anything that can be gained from that.”
Why the questions keep coming back
This is the third time the 2018 findings have been challenged. CA’s original inquiry concluded that only Smith, Warner and Bancroft knew of the plan. In 2021 Bancroft told the Guardian it was “pretty probably self-explanatory” whether the bowlers had known. Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon responded with a joint statement saying they “did not know a foreign substance was taken on to the field,” and CA did not reopen the case.
Khawaja’s account is harder to set aside. He played 88 Tests, says he sat next to Bancroft at Newlands, and says CA investigators never interviewed him. Darren Lehmann, the coach at the time, has disputed the claim that the whole squad knew. The Australian Cricketers’ Association called the tour a “low point for Australian cricket” and said the banned trio paid an “enormous” and “disproportionate” price.
Clarke’s intervention matters because of what the scandal went on to shape. The bans set the order of Australia’s captaincy for the next eight years, and the bowlers cleared in 2018 went on to lead the attack, with Cummins captaining the side. As long as CA declines to reopen the case and the senior players say nothing, the competing accounts will stand side by side.
“I would just like to see whatever the truth is for it all to come out,” Clarke said, “allow people to finally tell the truth, and move on.”












