Australia doomed to live with stench of sandpapergate

Australia doomed to live with stench of sandpapergate
⏱ 3 min read  •  777 words

Related Teams

Eight years after Cameron Bancroft was caught on camera with sandpaper at Newlands, Usman Khawaja’s autobiography has left Australian cricket stuck where it started. Sabr was published on Tuesday. Khawaja batted at number three in that Cape Town Test and sat next to Bancroft in the dressing room, and his verdict on 2018 is “It was all of us.” On the same day, Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg said he saw no “compelling reason” to reopen the investigation.

Writing for BBC Sport, cricket correspondent Stephan Shemilt argues that the result is a stalemate with no way out. Khawaja has hinted at wider knowledge without naming anyone. CA says that is not enough to act on. The four bowlers at the centre of the speculation stand by a denial they issued five years ago.

Close to the line, but not over it

Shemilt notes that Khawaja has chosen his words carefully, possibly for legal reasons. Borrowing Nathan Lyon’s old line about Australia knowing how to “headbutt the line”, he writes that Khawaja has done the same to whistle-blowing without going all the way. In the book, Khawaja says he uses “we” because “‘we’ are team Australia”. He also says he is “not speaking on behalf of anyone but myself.”

Khawaja has retreated further since the extracts appeared on 7 November. In an Instagram video he said “all of us” meant collective responsibility, and he told ABC: “I’m not here to go on a witch hunt.” His central claims are attributed to the book and remain unproven: that sandpaper was first used during the previous Test at Port Elizabeth, that a member of the backroom staff encouraged Bancroft, and that CA never interviewed him.

Others have taken sides. David Warner, Khawaja’s childhood friend, backed him in his own video but did not name anyone else. Seamer Chadd Sayers, who was in the 2018 squad, has also supported him. Former captain Michael Clarke went on 2DayFM to call for the case to be reopened, warning that without action supporters cannot “trust what’s real”. Darren Lehmann, the coach at the time, has not changed his position. Mitchell Starc says Port Elizabeth was the first he had heard of the claim and that he has no plans to read the book.

Why the bowlers cannot escape it

The original sanctions fell on three men. Smith and Warner were banned for 12 months and Bancroft for nine. Smith also lost the captaincy, and his successor Tim Paine later resigned over his own scandal. Shemilt goes through that Newlands XI to show how few have been accounted for. Three players were punished. Khawaja has now accepted his share of responsibility. Paine and the brothers Mitchell and Shaun Marsh make seven. Mitchell Marsh is due to captain Australia in the white-ball series against England and is scheduled to speak to the media on Thursday.

The bowlers are where it matters most. Pat Cummins, Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Lyon have 1,678 Test wickets between them. Cummins is the current captain and has won the Ashes and a World Cup. In 2021 the four said they “did not know a foreign substance was taken on to the field” and they have stuck to that. The umpires saw no reason to change the ball at Newlands. Khawaja argues that sandpaper leaves visible swirls on the leather.

Cummins, Hazlewood, Lyon and Smith had not commented publicly on the book as of 10 November. As Shemilt puts it, “it is hard to prove a negative.”

What CA could still do

The files from CA’s Cape Town investigation have never been published. In 2021 David Saker, an assistant coach on the 2018 tour, called for them to be released. Khawaja does not name Saker, but the book implicates the coaching staff, and Shemilt argues that claim alone deserves scrutiny. Greenberg’s position is that the specific details in the book contradict what CA already knows. CA has said it is “comfortable” with its integrity process and will consider new information.

Shemilt suggests one way out: the four bowlers could call for the investigation to be reopened themselves, which might clear their names. The other possibility is that the people in charge would rather not find out what a new inquiry might uncover. Both of Australia’s previous two Test captains lost the job in disgrace.

The timing matters. Over the coming year the same bowlers will try to win a Test series in India and an Ashes series in England, two things they have not yet done. Until somebody new comes forward, whether a player, a coach or CA, any success they have will come with questions about 2018 attached.

Ahmad Ali
Written by
Ahmad Ali

Sports journalist and editor at SportsPortal.net. Covers cricket, football, Formula 1, tennis, and basketball with a focus on how global sports connect with Pakistani audiences. Follows the PSL, Pakistan national cricket team, Premier League, and major international tournaments. Has reported on sports for digital audiences since 2021.

1183 articles published